be well organized, with a clear argument and concrete examples to support it;
feature an introduction and conclusion, with logical paragraph development throughout;
include corroboration from outside sources (articles, books, database entries, non-Wikipedia webpages, and others)
be word-processed and thoroughly proofread.
youre not being asked to give a thumbs-up or thumbs-down on the pieces under consideration. Rather, your job is to describe your perception of the works, what they have and dont have in common, and their broader significance.